Pony Pines is a distinctive residential community in Port St. Lucie known for its spacious homesites, peaceful rural atmosphere, mature trees, and equestrian-friendly character. The neighborhood is relatively small, with approximately 42 homes, creating a private setting with quiet streets and plenty of open space. Many properties feature expansive single-family homes on large lots, with room for private pools, detached structures, recreational vehicles, and outdoor living areas, while the community’s farmland-style surroundings provide a unique contrast to Port St. Lucie’s more traditional suburban neighborhoods. Pony Pines also has an active property owners association that has been established since the 1970s, reflecting the neighborhood’s long-standing residential history. Despite its peaceful setting, residents remain conveniently connected to shopping, dining, schools, healthcare services, parks, and major roadways, with newer development and residential growth continuing in the surrounding area. With its larger homesites, natural surroundings, established character, and sense of privacy, Pony Pines offers a distinctive option for those seeking a more spacious and relaxed lifestyle in Port St. Lucie. Click on a listing to view the property details, photos and agent comments. If you would like to change or expand your search criteria, go back to the main Port Saint Lucie FL Real Estate page, or try using our Advanced Search.